HP and the half-blood prince beware:Spoiler

[Moryarity]

Hi, everyone, who as already read the book, feel free to discuss, all others beware, this will be full of Spoiler, so don´t read further if you want to read it yourself :biggrin:












So, my opinion:


A really good book! The question ist, if Snape is really a bad guy, or if Albus death is just a kind of masterplan....and an interesting point of view, is Harry the last horcruxes and the line of the prophecy is therefore:neither can live, while the other survives........what is your opinion...

[conquestare legionare]

just for correction but HP is a computer company !.and also the short word for health points in games.

[Moryarity]

well, but HP is also the commonly used short form of Harry Potter :biggrin:

[Heretic]

It's a pity I haven't noticed this new HP book published in Lithuania yet and I haven't read it, so can't share my impressions :cheers:
(No spoilers, please :cool: )

[Moryarity]

sad you haven´t it. I bought it from the UK because in Germany it will be published on 1th of october..so I already tread it in english :cool: Sems nobody else is reading it :sad:

[Helen]

I've read it :D

I still believe Snape is a "good" guy, and it was indeed a plan that might went wrong (He had no choice to kill him since there were.. 4 Deatheaters in the room? - he had to show he still "stands" with Voldemort when he infact still are on Dumbledore side)

[Moryarity]

I agree with you Helen:

I even suggest it was Dumbledors plan...I think, he was poisoned or cursed because he destroied Gaunts ring and that he was dying anyway..so he made out that plan, to integrate Snape back in Voldemorts rows.....I also think, that is why they argued in the forest, Snape didn´t want to do it, but dumbledore convinced him...and in the end, when Dumbledore is pleading, he is pleadinh, that snape is following the plan and kill him....I really think is a good guy and that Harry is the last horcrux..ans I think, that snape was at Godrics Hallow, the night Harrys parents died to take him away and save him, and that this is the cause, that Dumbledore trusts him so much..I think he was a spy right from the beginning!

[karima]

I'm reading it at the moment, I've only just heard about these horcruxes, and after reading your posts, I want to read on now!

[Moryarity]

Thats great :go: Then you can join the discussion :biggrin:

[mamayourpeoplearehungry]

I have also read it. I got it on Saturday morning the first day it was for sale and I finished it by Sunday evening.

I also believe that Snape will still turn out to be a good guy. I was wondering why Harry wanted to get Snape to come back and reverse the curse to save Dumbledore. Can the curse be reversed? If it can has Dumbledore already had it reversed? I also think that Harry is the last horcrux. I also think that Snape had taken an oath to protect Harry also, or maybe his being a horcrux is why Voldemort doesn't want anyone else to kill Harry other than himself.

By the way, why would Snape being at Grimwalt Place (Sirius's home) have anything to do with saving Harry at his parent's home? The one who saved Harry was his mother with the help of Dumbledore.

I wonder how many of the horcruxes will be found at Grimwalt Place. The locket was found there in the last book when they were cleaning up. I don't think it was destroyed though as noone could open it. RAB - Sirius's brother Regulus? Was he also a death eater that turned on Voldemort? We know that Voldemort had him killed.

What does anyone think of Aunt Petunia? Was she invited to go to school at Hogwarts and decided not to only to have her younger sister go and do well? Does she also have powers?

[Moryarity]

concerning Grimault place, that was an error of me, I wanted to say Godrics Hallow, the place where Harrys parents lived....

Regulus was -as far it is said- a rather bad wizard with little skills, and he was a death Eater, he betrayed Voldemort and was kiles by him for yet unknown reason....so maybe he has something to do with it..and he is named in the 6th book, although it would not have been necessary....was that a hint?

Petunia is lso strange to me...but she always hated her sister for her powers..maybe she wanted to be "normal" not using any powers, but maybe she have some....

[the knightly sword]

just for correction but HP is a computer company !.and also the short word for health points in games.

cl now behave before i throw a nimbus up your buttom :lol: :lol: .

[conquestare legionare]

Alex im gonna kick your arse for saying that !! grrrr :angry:

[karima]

I've finally finished reading, and I think that book's strange. What about the Prime Minister stuff, for example? There are many things that are not at all clear, and I wonder how she'll proceed in the next book. When will it be released, anyway?

Harry being the last Horcrux seems possible to me, too. Voldemort has given him some of his powers (Parzel etc.) and they are somehow connected, which could be seen clearly in the last book.

[Moryarity]

JKR said she will pause writing for six months and then start with the last book..the last chapter however has been writtten for several years nad is safe in her house :biggrin:


There are many strange things...and how strange Dumbledore behaves..ok..he knows, that he is in danger, and that Drco is in it..and he is doing nothing......to get information maybe, but when the first "accident" happend, he should have done something..that s not at all Dumbledore like..to put the pupils in danger...

[karima]

And why was the book called "The Half-Blood Prince"? The Prince was not really important, was he? Okay, Snape was important, especially in the end. :biggrin: But the Prince wasn't.

[conquestare legionare]

snape is quite ugly.dumbledore is too child friendly and pretty stupid. In my opinion voldemort is the true hero.

[Moryarity]

And why was the book called "The Half-Blood Prince"? The Prince was not really important, was he? Okay, Snape was important, especially in the end. :biggrin: But the Prince wasn't.


well, why was the forth band called "the goblet of fire" it was also not important.....

but snape is "The half-blood prince" it is quiet important..and his book is helping Harry throughout the year..although it seems quiet impossible that it was Snpes book originally..as it is 50 years old..but it belonged to his mother..and maybe he used her writings..and added some more, but this is also one of the strange things in this book


and..i think snape is the true hero :lol:

[karima]

In the fourth book, the whole story begins because of the Goblet (As you don't know for a long time that it was the fake Moody how caused the Goblet to accept another name). So it is important.

[Moryarity]

As you don't know for a long time that it was the fake Moody how caused the Goblet to accept another name. So it is important.


Well, to be honest, Moody was my first guess...just when I read the scene in the room after teh choosing I knew it was him :sad: the whole book I hoped not to be right..but well, I was :sad:


but the goblet only appears in that one scene and is not important in the whole plot therafter.....so it is not more important than Snape is in this book..I would say, the "half-blood" princes book and the question who he is, is present in the whole book..although i guessed it was snape :biggrin: